In the study phase,JLRDevaluated offerings from the different chiller manufacturers, current and projected cooling load
requirements, as well as the physical constraints associated with replacement machines. A failure of one of the (3) original 500 ton R-11 chillers provided the impetus to perform the study, which evaluated replacing the existing
original equipment with either the same or larger size machines, changing the chiller voltage from the current 4,160 volts to 480 volts utilizing variable frequency drive machines, replacement of the cooling towers, addressing
pumping systems, system operational issues and obsolete, primitive central plant controls.
With outage periods limited to 6-hours, replacing the chillers and the cooling towers with a common, shared basin configuration proved to be a challenge. In order to perform the work during the cooler months, a pre-purchase strategy
was used for the chillers, towers and electrical switchgear, which allowed the work to be completed within the designated cool weather time frame. Due to the limited nighttime shutdown windows,JLRDwas on-site during
critical operations to observe the work being performed, and to provide real-time responses to construction issues as they arose.
As part of the chiller procurement process,JLRDrecommended for the Owner to consider options for increased chiller efficiency due to the 24/7 operation of the facility. Life cycle costing justified the added expense showing
a conservative, under 3-year payback, by increasing the chiller efficiency from 0.556 KW/ton to 0.511 KW/ton. To provide further savings, the cooling tower water make-up and blowdown were metered to eliminate being charged
for discharge to sanitary for evaporated water, with the first year savings exceeding $14,000.00.
The configuration of the primary chilled water piping in the existing plant precluded the simultaneous use of existing Chillers 4 (600 tons) and 5 (800 tons). As part of the design, the piping was reconfigured in a manner that
now allows these machines to be run simultaneously, providing increased plant operational flexibility. A new DDC-based chiller plant control system was installed as part of the project and provides for automatic staging of
the chillers, towers and pumps to meet the demand load.
This project exemplifies JLRD’s experience in large tonnage chiller plants, proficiency with phased type of equipment replacements with limited duration outage periods, ability to identify and correct system operational
issues, focus on system efficiency and impact to operational costs, and our responsiveness to construction administration.